Thus, for example, when we say that a college is justified in expelling a student who falls below a passing mark, we are acknowledging that the college has a right to set certain standards of performance and to require its students to meet them. In most societies, killing a human being is seen as a bad thing to do. But what do you do when a country declares war against you? If you do nothing and stick to your moral grounds, you will be destroyed, but the war will be over.
Does the End Justify the Means? Machiavelli knew full well that politicians could and did rise to power using dirty tricks. He considered deception a fair tool in war.
But the end was different for each, and that created the moral. He devoted himself to the military profession and he rose to the rank of Praetor — a magistrate — of Syracuse. During this time, the Carthaginian army was fighting to conquer Sicily.
Agathocles made a deal with its general to halt his attacks against Syracuse while Agathocles took control of the city from inside.
The general thought he was gaining an ally to help him overthrow the city. Agathocles first made a bold move by tricking the people of Syracuse: At a given signal, the soldiers killed all the senators and the richest men in the city.
Once they were dead, he seized and held the princedom of that city without any civil commotion. He routed them in battle twice, and successfully defended the city against their siege. While besieged, Agathocles took part of his force and attacked the Carthaginian cities in North Africa which forced the enemy army to retreat.
Syracuse prospered as a result. Agathocles did not rely on luck, but on his own talents and cunning, to achieve his success and Machiavelli always appreciated men with talent: Such methods may gain empire, but not glory… his barbarous cruelty and inhumanity… do not permit him to be celebrated among the most excellent men.
But even so, Machiavelli admires him for his boldness, courage and skill.
They thought he would reward them, later. He entered the city with one hundred horsemen, plus his friends and retainers, under pretense of needing an honour guard to show off his patrimony. He convinced his uncle, Giovanni, to allow him in and to tell the citizens his large and armed group was not a threat to the city.
What is offered for free is dangerous — it usually involves a trick or a hidden obligation. Oliverotto made himself the ruler — prince — of Fermo that night after terrifying the rest of the people into obedience: In fear the people were forced — obey him, and to form a government, with himself as prince.
III, 48 And in this case, it was a trap that Giovanni and the rest fell into. Machiavelli admired skillful cunning, too, not just talent or a skillful use of force: II, 13 Over the weeks and months that followed, Oliverotto continued his reign of terror.
Well-Used Cruelty So what was the difference Machiavelli was trying to highlight in these two similar tales? Cruelty as a tool for political ends?
Machiavelli breaks away from the traditional fixed morality of Aristotle and the church with this comment. No one before had ever suggested cruelty could be used in a creative way for the greater good.
There are good and bad ways to be cruel, he tells us. Those who practice the first system are able… to maintain their rule, as Agathocles did. It is impossible for those who follow the other method to survive. But if, like Oliverotto, the ruler continues to use force and is unable to save the state against opposition, then it was not justified.The End Justifies The Means Idea Essay One of the major politics thinkers known to us is Niccolo Machiavelli.
He is popular for the key phrase "the finish justifies the means" which is regularly being the subject of discussions and discourses today (Adams and Dyson). Mar 02, · I haven't posted in a while, and I need to change that. Recently, the debatable topic of "does the end justify the means" has been creeping its way back into my life again.
Coincidentally, I found (while digging through my old work, of course) an essay that I wrote a few years ago debating that. The End Justifies the Means Essay A philosopher once said However, this also brings on moral and ethical controversy.
What the statement 'The End Justifies the Means' means to me is simply this: The 'End' simply means that it is the end of a complex or simple goal.
We will write a custom essay sample on What did Machiavelli mean by the statement “the end justifies the means”? specifically for you for only $ $/page. One of the major political thinkers known to us is Niccolo Machiavelli.
He is well known for the phrase "the end justifies the means" which is continually being the subject of discussions and discourses today (Adams and Dyson). Lesley Rawlins The end justifies the means The end justifies the means is an expression that is often used in society to validate or excuse distasteful and.
code of ethics for interpreters essays Read this essay . Essay, term paper research paper on Gun Control.